Cooling off on global warming
By John K. Carlisle
The American public is going cold on global warming.
For more than a decade, environmentalists have warned that man-made greenhouse gases are causing a litany of environmental disasters such as soaring temperatures, melting glaciers and a sharp rise in sea levels that would flood seaboard cities.
But these dire warnings are increasingly falling on deaf ears because environmentalists can't back up their apocalyptic predictions with evidence. Ruefully noted John Immerwahr, who conducted a study for the American Geophysical Union, "The more we talk about global warming, the [more the] public's concern goes down."
Hence, the environmental movement's insistence on making global warming the theme for this year's Earth Day in an attempt to keep it on the media radar screen will only jade a public weary of an issue whose hype isn't matched by the reality.
Take the predictions of rapid warming. Officials with the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the body that has been the principal advocate of the global warming theory, have admitted that their predictions of major temperature increases were wrong. In 1990, the IPCC predicted that global temperatures would rise 6° F by 2100. Just three years later, the IPCC adjusted its warming projection downward, forecasting that temperatures would rise less than 2° F, a noticeable temperature increase but hardly a cause for concern. Natural temperature increases of 3° to 4° F have occurred in past centuries and have generally benefited humanity by prolonging growing seasons and promoting mild weather.
But it is significant that the world's temperature is not rising. Predictions of global warming are not coming true. NASA's Tiros weather satellites, the most accurate barometers of global temperature, show that the Earth has slightly cooled since 1979, contradicting global warming doomsayers who predicted that human-induced warming should have caused the temperature to increase 0.6° F by now.
Recent scientific research is also disproving claims that global warming is causing the sea level to dangerously rise. In October 1999, a team of scientists led by Dr. Howard Conway of the University of Washington reported that the massive West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS), considered to be especially vulnerable to alleged global warming, is not melting due to human influences. Dr. Conway said the gradual melting of the WAIS "appears to be part of an ongoing natural cycle" of melting that began when the ice age ended 10,000 years ago. It will take several thousand years before this melting ice sheet would even begin to affect seaboard cities - assuming the Earth doesn't enter a new ice age.
In light of such mounting evidence, environmentalist efforts to claim scientific support for the global warming theory are foundering. The Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), a liberal advocacy organization, points to the 1,500 scientists who signed a 1997 UCS document endorsing major cuts in greenhouse gases as evidence of scientific support for the global warming theory. But since then, nearly 17,000 scientists have signed a petition, organized by the Oregon Institute of Science and Medicine, which declares that, "There is no convincing scientific evidence that human release of... greenhouse gases is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere." The signers include 2,100 climatologists, meteorologists and environmental scientists who are especially well-qualified to evaluate the effects of carbon dioxide on the Earth's climate.
Given the deepening scientific and public skepticism over global warming, environmentalists would have done better to choose another issue as their theme for Earth Day 2000. When it comes to global warming, environmentalists may have cried wolf one too many times.
John K. Carlisle is the director of The National Center for Public Policy Research's Environmental Policy Task Force. Comments may be sent to JCarlisle@nationalcenter.org. The center can be found at http://www.nationalcenter.org
© 1996-2018, Enter Stage Right and/or its creators. All rights reserved.