home > archive > 2009 > this article


Search this site Search WWW

It's Groundhog Day in the Middle East

By Alan Caruba
web posted November 2, 2009

In the movie, Groundhog Day, the main character wakes up day after day, trapped in the same events, desperately looking for a way out of that living nightmare. It's a very good metaphor for the Middle East.

Here are some quotes from a book whose title I will reveal in a moment:

"The only truly transcendent law in the Middle East is that of unintended consequences."

"Nation-building and the redressing of historic wrongs were in the air…"

"His fighters secured control of key rivers, recaptured Kut, and on (date withheld) stormed victoriously into Baghdad. Still undecided was how this famous city—and, indeed, most of Mesopotamia—would now be governed."

"I suppose we have underestimated the fact that this country is really an inchoate mass of tribes which can't as yet be reduced to any system. The Turks didn't govern and we have tried to govern…and failed."

And finally "Our armies have come into your cities and lands not as conquerors or enemies, but as liberators."

All this and more was said in the 1920s by British imperialists. If it sounds like things being said by Americans, then you must assume that America has been repeating all the mistakes of Great Britain in the exact same places.

The book being quoted is Kingmakers: The Invention of the Modern Middle East by Karl E. Mayer and Shareen Blair Brysac ($18.95, W.W. Norton, softcover) and its five-hundred pages are devoted to the extraordinary personalities of the 1920s who, believing it was Great Britain's duty was to bring civilization to India, Africa, and the Middle East, devoted themselves to "Pax Britannia", the rule of distant colonies representing a fourth of the world's population.

The book is a reminder that whatever passes for modernity in the Middle East has generally been imposed by the process of European colonization in quest of its oil and other riches to fatten the profits of various British, French, and American business enterprises such as the Suez Canal and the oil companies.

Left to themselves the polyglot of tribes would never have experienced anything resembling modernization.

Afghanistan today would look very much the same to the earliest invaders and explorers who passed through it. No roads. No hospitals. Few schools. No jobs except raising poppies for the heroin trade or serving in the army or police. Men raised from youth to fight anyone and everyone. Pushtuns, Tajiks, Hazarus, Uzbeks, Turkmen, and Qizilbash.

The Middle East had been ruled by the Turkish Ottoman Empire for centuries—from Egypt to Persia. Going back even further in history, the region was no stranger to European invasions. The Crusades were a response against the Islamic invaders that, at one point, laid siege to Vienna.

As the authors note, "In his history of Jerusalem, the Israeli writer Amos Elon calculates that over four millennia the Holy City has known 'twenty ruinous sieges, two intervals of total destruction, eighteen recent reconstructions, and at least eleven transitions from one religion to another." In 1967 visitors could find the remnants of "Roman encampments, Crusader castles, Turkish parapets, and British pillboxes."

To suggest, for example, that after more than sixty years of Israeli national sovereignty that Arab neighbor nations (and Iran) have the slightest intention of allowing it to exist is to ignore the history of centuries old intolerance directed against both Christian and Jew.

Following World War One, England and France divided the remains of the Ottoman Empire that had chosen to side with Germany. It would have died sooner or later of its own dead weight, but it was Sir Percy Zachariah Cox who would take out "a map and a pencil to draw the boundary between Iraq and the Nejd (now Saudi Arabia). The borders with Syria and Transjordan were defined similarly."

There were Arab leaders, but they were generally the pawns of the great powers, frequently assassinated or deposed. The nations of the Middle East are, for the most part, ruled by monarchs and despots.

As the British Empire shrank in the wake of World War Two and American power grew, only one thing is clear. Neither of these imperial powers had any clue, nor way of solving the Middle East's regressive Islamic fanaticism that remains a ceaseless threat to Western civilization. And, as in past times, the debates rage about staying in or getting out.

Every day in the Middle East is Groundhog Day. ESR

Alan Caruba writes a daily post at http://factsnotfantasy.blogspot.com. A business and science writer, author, he is the founder of The National Anxiety Center.  © Alan Caruba, October 2009

 

Send a link to this page!
Send a link to this story

 

Home


 

Home

Site Map

E-mail ESR

ESR's blog

 

Send a link to this page!
Send a link to this story



Get weekly updates about new issues of ESR!
e-mail:
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

 

1996-2013, Enter Stage Right and/or its creators. All rights reserved.